Does Hell Exist?
Last week’s article, Why I Am Not A Universalist, has led to some awesome conversations, both in-person and online. On Monday I was asked on Facebook if I believed in “a literal hell, not just the effects, like condemnation and shame and so on, but a literal fiery place of eternal torment?” I posted my response on Facebook and it led to more amazing interactions.
The interactions have been generous and open-hearted so I thought I would post my Facebook response as this week’s article that we might continue the conversation.
If you haven’t read, Why I Am Not A Universalist, please do before reading this as it will help add context to the thoughts in my response below. That said, I have done some editing to my response as well as added thoughts at the end to help articulate further.
Finally, I am aware that many have strong feelings regarding the subject of hell. My thoughts are not definitive. Please take them as suggestions from a fellow traveler who is leaning into His love and let not your heart be troubled.
“Do you believe in a literal hell, not just the effects, like condemnation and shame and so on, but a literal fiery place of eternal torment?”
Here are my thoughts on the subject of hell as of Oct 28, 2019.
I don’t know if hell is a literal place. I don’t understand how a timeless paradigm works. But whether it’s a place or not, I do believe it’s an experience and I believe it exists after this life.
When it comes to hell, here’s the real issue for me, I don’t believe God is about punishment (See – Why I Am Not A Universalist). Punishment says something about the nature of God I just don’t see in the life, death, and resurrection of Christ. So how does hell work?
One scripture that has helped me understand heaven and hell is Matt 6:22-23. Jesus said, “The eye is the lamp of the body. If your eyes are healthy, your whole body will be full of light. But if your eyes are unhealthy, your whole body will be full of darkness. If then the light within you is darkness, how great is that darkness!”
I think hell is the result of truth (Love) being rejected. When this happens, light, love, wholeness, and life are perceived as darkness, hate, brokenness, and death. And how great is that hell… Essentially, while punishment can certainly be in humanity’s perspective, it has never been in God’s nature.
When our eyes, (our perception) are true (Jesus) heaven is the result; grace is the result, life, light, and love.
If our perception is flawed, if we reject the truth of His love, we will experience hell or punishment.
I don’t know why this wouldn’t hold true after this life.
And, of course, this raises the big “scary question” I have avoided answering outside of small groups for years simply because I knew my thoughts might possibly offend folks and I wasn’t yet sure enough in love to be bold enough to write them down.
“Do you believe our Father’s love and redemption is available to us after we die?”
Yes. Why, because God is love.
God is love. Love is greater and grander and still measureless (Eph 3:16-20). Love is fully available to us in life and death (Rom 8:38-39). Love is a relentless redeemer and nothing separates us from His nature (Luke 23:34). Death doesn’t end His great affection for us. He is still there, His love is still available to us (Rom 8:38-39). His nature doesn’t change simply because we have rejected Him.
The only way love works in my understanding is that we are free to choose. The idea that we can’t receive or reject His love after this life is in direct conflict with the nature of Love. (see “A Few More Thoughts” below for more on this)
Satan was free to choose long before we had words to describe the consequences of his rejection; his story suggests free will existed before time existed, at least in the way we understand time (Isaiah 14:12-15). Adam and Eve were also free to choose, they lived heaven on earth and chose to reject the perfection of His love and that’s when hell entered their narrative.
So if God is love and His love chases us down even in death as Paul writes in Romans, then I don’t know how there won’t be opportunities to both receive and reject His love on the other side of this life.
This raises a new question…
“How does this work after we die?”
I have no idea. But to be honest, I don’t think I need to. It’s not where my focus is. I believe Jesus wanted heaven on earth (Matt 6:10). So, when it comes to hell, my focus is very much connected to the here and now. It’s not that what happens when we die isn’t important, it’s just that I believe my ability to understand it is greatly connected to how sure I am in His love in the here and now. I’m only 45, I have eternity to discover the measureless, miraculous, mind transforming goodness of His affection.
One last thought, I would like to suggest that any thought about hell that isn’t interpreted through a measureless revelation of heaven should be held suspect; any conclusion about hell that isn’t birthed from sovereign love, Jesus on a cross, is flawed and therefore dangerous to our spiritual and emotional well-being.
I have found that those who tend to preach most fervently on the horrors of hell and eternal damnation seem to have very little evidence of the Kingdom of heaven in their lives. You know, the righteousness, peace, and joy in the Holy Spirit that Paul wrote about in Romans 14:17. Those last two evidences, peace and joy? They are often markedly absent.
You don’t understand a lie by studying the lie, you understand a lie by becoming immersed in the truth. His love, revealed perfectly in the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus, is the truth. And I’m convinced this is where life is discovered and also where understanding regarding heaven and hell is discovered.
Anyway, those are my thoughts 🙂would love to hear yours.
A Few More Thoughts…
Regarding the “scary question” of whether free will exists after we die.
“I believe hell exists, and I am not a universalist.”
I’m not suggesting that this life and the decisions made here aren’t important. I believe decisions have consequences. However, I don’t believe consequences are about punishment. The idea of punishment says something about the nature of God that I just can’t find in the life, death, and resurrection of Christ.
I grew up being taught that heaven and hell were about punishment and reward. I don’t believe that anymore. I believe the idea of punishment is absolutely contrary to the love Jesus revealed.
As far as whether or not there is free will after this life, it’s an interesting conversation, but honestly, not one I’m going to lose sleep over. When it comes to heaven and hell, I’m more focused on what both mean for the here and now.
That said, personally, I don’t know how love would work without free will, so I’m OK with it existing after we die.
Here’s what I’m convinced of: God is love. He is perfectly revealed through Jesus, and He is always good. His love continues to be better than I think. Also, at the end of the day, my goal in life is to grow in His affection and live as a revelation of His love.
My friend, Joshua Fletcher, posted a great 3 minute video from N.T. Wright on hell. I think his thoughts are insightful and helpful.
Also, here is a great article by Wright on the early church view regarding heaven. The New Testament Doesn’t Say What Most People Think It Does About Heaven
Jason Clark is a writer, speaker and lead communicator at A Family Story ministries. His mission is to encourage sons and daughters to grow sure in the love of an always-good heavenly Father. He and his wife, Karen, live in North Carolina with their three children.
YOU ALSO MIGHT LIKE…